CYBERNETICS AND MENTAL FUNCTIONING

R. W. Thomson, W. Sluckin · 1953 · The British Journal for the Philosophy …

paper 4 of 19 on this spine peer review →

Can machines think, and what does it mean for human cognition?

THE ITCH THE FIELD HAD, BEFORE THIS PAPER

The Problem of Mental Functioning

Imagine a puppeteer controlling a marionette, but the puppeteer is also being controlled by another puppeteer. This creates a complex feedback loop where the puppeteer's actions are influenced by the other puppeteer's actions, and vice versa. This analogy represents the problem of mental functioning, where the mind is seen as a system that processes information and responds to

IN PLAIN TERMSThe human mind is a complex system that processes information and responds to external stimuli, but is also influenced by internal factors such as emotions, memories, and experiences. This creates a problem for understanding mental functioning, as it is difficult to separate the internal and externa

The Mechanism of Feedback Loops

In the puppeteer-marionette analogy, the feedback loop is created when the puppeteer's actions are influenced by the other puppeteer's actions. This creates a cycle of cause and effect, where the puppeteer's actions are the effect of the other puppeteer's actions, and the other puppeteer's actions are the effect of the puppeteer's actions. This cycle of feedback is essential fo

IN PLAIN TERMSFeedback loops are a key mechanism in mental functioning, where the output of a system is used as input to the same system, creating a cycle of cause and effect. This mechanism is essential for understanding how the mind processes information and responds to external stimuli.

The Future of Cybernetics

In the puppeteer-marionette analogy, the future of cybernetics is represented by the possibility of creating a system that can control itself, without the need for external control. This is achieved by creating a feedback loop that is self-sustaining, where the system's output is used as input to the same system, creating a cycle of cause and effect that is self-perpetuating. T

IN PLAIN TERMSThe future of cybernetics is represented by the possibility of creating machines that can think and learn without the need for external control. This is achieved by creating self-sustaining feedback loops that allow machines to process information and respond to external stimuli without the need for

[ THE MODEL TO WALK AWAY WITH ]

The mind is a system that processes information and responds to external stimuli through feedback loops, where the output of the system is used as input to the same system, creating a cycle of cause a

Reach for it when

When designing complex systems that require feedback loops, such as control systems or artificial intelligence.
When understanding human cognition and behavior, as feedback loops play a key role in mental functioning.
When creating machines that can think and learn, as self-sustaining feedback loops are essential for machine learning.

It misleads when

When assuming that feedback loops are linear, rather than cyclical, as this can lead to incorrect conclusions about ment
When ignoring the internal factors that influence behavior, as feedback loops are influenced by both internal and extern
When assuming that machines can think and learn without the need for external control, as this is still a topic of debat

Try it in your world

Founder

Create a feedback loop in a product to improve user engagement, by using user data to inform product development.

WHY · Feedback loops are essential for understanding user behavior and improving product development, as t

Use machine learning algorithms to create self-sustaining feedback loops in a product, to improve performance and efficiency.

WHY · Self-sustaining feedback loops are essential for machine learning, as they allow machines to process

ProductLeader

Use feedback loops to understand user behavior and improve product development, by analyzing user data and feedback.

WHY · Feedback loops are essential for understanding user behavior and improving product development, as t

Create a product that uses self-sustaining feedback loops to improve performance and efficiency, by using machine learning algorithms.

WHY ·

Researcher

Investigate the role of feedback loops in mental functioning, by analyzing human behavior and cognition.

WHY · Feedback loops play a key role in mental functioning, and understanding their role is essential for

Develop new machine learning algorithms that use self-sustaining feedback loops to improve performance and efficiency.

WHY ·

Engineer

Design a system that uses feedback loops to improve performance and efficiency, by using machine learning algorithms and self-sustaining fee

WHY · Feedback loops are essential for improving performance and efficiency, as they allow machines to pro

Implement a product that uses self-sustaining feedback loops to improve performance and efficiency, by using machine learning algorithms.

WHY ·

← 1952 · “The Status of Brain in the Concept of Mind” 1953 · Computers and Automata →